"This working paper aims to synthesize current efforts to develop comparable evaluation methods for social issue documentary films. Authored by two researchers who have been jointly documenting the field’s transformation over the past five years, this paper offers a framework for planning and evaluating the impact of these films in a networked media environment ... Drawing insights from the design thinking field—a user-focused creation process that has emerged from the commercial design field and is now being applied to create and improve social sector projects—this working paper examines state-of-the art methodologies for strategic design and evaluation of documentaries. The report’s recommendations are informed by lessons from six case studies of representative films: A Lion in the House; The Line; Lioness; Not in Our Town; Out in the Silence; and State of Fear. These are all award-winning projects featuring compelling documentary films at the center of multiplatform strategic outreach campaigns. All have been screened in traditional broadcast and/or film festival settings, as well as venues designed to engage publics and mobilize advocates relevant to the issue being addressed. These producers utilize a variety of technologies and both online and offline organizing tactics. At their most powerful, they catalyze and support issue-based networks that connect individuals with relevant organizations and empower participants not only to learn about and discuss shared problems, but to organize for action and respond to breaking developments. In this way, documentaries feed both social movements and the broader public sphere." (Introduction)
Contents
EVALUATING DOCUMENTARY, THE STATE OF THE FIELD
Why Now? 6
Current Methods, 7
Missing Links, 10
Case Studies, 14
Case Study Takeaways, 19
APPENDIX I: HOW SHOULD FUNDERS AND FILMMAKERS INTEGRATE STRATEGIC DESIGN AND EVALUATION? 23
APPENDIX II: CASE STUDIES
A Lion in The House, 26
The Line, 32
Lioness, 39
Not In Our Town, 46
Out In The Silence, 53
State Of Fear: The Truth About Terrorism, 59
APPENDIX III: RELATED VISUALIZATIONS, 66