Document detail

'Screening' transitional justice in Serbia: ICTY representations and the memory of war crimes in Serb television media

Osnabrück: Deutsche Stiftung Friedensforschung (DSF) (2019), 41 pp., bibliogr. p.34-39
ISSN 2193-794X
"The visual presentation of the Serb accused in TV news was based on iconic images of the accused combined with symbolic images of the state and its power, with nearly complete absence of visuals of atrocities and victims. In contrast, the visual presentation of the Croatian, Bosniak and Albanian defendants draws meaning mainly from sequences of images displaying victims, war destruction or attacks as “palpable” proof of crimes. This supports a sentiment of collective victimhood of the Serb population and creates the impression of the indicted persons’ guilt even after their acquittals by the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY). Since the research project has been limited to three Serb TV channels, comparative work on TV media in other states of former Yugoslavia would be required in order to assess how ’special’ the case of Serbia is regarding these visual strategies. The much disputed legitimacy of the ICTY and the important role of media have also become obvious in focus groups interviews with students in Serbia: The students displayed a striking lack of knowledge about war crimes; nonetheless, they strongly rejected the ICTY as a biased institution. At the same time, they were perceptive of new facts and interpretations, showing that they have a genuine need to understand the past and obtain objective information. A major problem is that in their perception there are few, if any, objective, neutral institutions which to put trust in. The expert interviews, conducted in Belgrade and The Hague, underlined the critical state of mainstream TV media in Serbia: They were assessed as not really independent, driven by entertainment formats, suspect to governmental pressure and failing in their watchdog functions. The interviewees also expressed a widespread disappointment about the state of affairs of transitional justice in Serbia." (Summary)
Contents
1 Introduction, 6
2 The perceived (i)legitimacy of the ICTY and the role of Serb media, 9
3 Theoretical framework: the mediation of suffering, 11
4 Methodological framework and the TV representation of ICTY trials, 13
5 Selected results of the TV news analysis: what is (not) shown, what is (not) seen, 22
6 Reception of ICTY trials and perceptions of transitional justice: Results from the field research, 26
7 Conclusions and perspectives for further research, 29